20-Year Crash Cost of Signalized RC3 Cloverleaf Could Exceed $25 Million

Rezul News/10751424
Analysis uses PennDOT data across projected 9.2 avoidable crashes per year for planned Bucks County, PA interchange

LANGHORNE, Pa. - Rezul -- Crashes projected by PennDOT for the cloverleaf at US1 and PA413 in Lower Bucks County could result in more than $25 million in avoidable economic harm, according to PennDOT data.

Using PennDOT's own Traffic and Safety Analysis Update (https://us1bucks.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10...) figure of 9.2 projected crashes annually, two signalized intersections – at Woods Drive and Pine Street/PA413, and at Gillam Avenue and Pine Street/PA413 – could impose more than $25 million in avoidable economic harm. This could be avoided through the use of an alternative design that would eliminate the cloverleaf and instead use connected service roads and a roundabout-based local road network to achieve highway and community safety and connectivity objectives.

In 2025, comprehensive loss due to traffic crashes was $2,295 to every man, woman, and child in Pennsylvania, according to PennDOT's 2025 Crash Facts & Statistics Report (https://www.pa.gov/content/dam/copapwp-pagov/en/penndot/documents/travelinpa/safety/documents/2025_cfb_linked.pdf). Using the report, this analysis leverages PennDOT average loss per incident and percentage of all crashes data across four crash categories to determine an average cost per crash:

More on Rezul News
Crash Category   Average Comprehensive Loss   % of all crashes

Property Damage Only   $14,505   52.7%

Possible Injury   $155,850   18.24%

Suspected Minor Injury   $280,486   24.73%

Suspected Serious Injury   $874,868   3.56%

Excluding fatal crashes, the average per-crash comprehensive loss was $137,806. When multiplied by the 9.2 crashes projected annually by PennDOT, the total impact every year of the two signalized intersections would be $1,267,815. This figure could be even higher, based on the statistically greater frequency of more severe crashes at signalized intersections. Including fatal crashes would increase the per crash average loss to $273,561.

The preceding analysis was reviewed by SAFE Highway Engineering, LLC. Calculations are based on 2025 dollars.

"Comprehensive loss" is a calculated measure of the full economic harm caused by a crash, and includes:
  • Medical costs (acute care, long‑term care, rehabilitation);
  • Emergency response (police, fire, EMS);
  • Lost productivity (missed work, long‑term disability);
  • Insurance impacts (claims, premiums, administrative costs);
  • Property damage (vehicles, infrastructure, roadside features);
  • Travel delay (congestion, detours, time lost);
  • Employer losses (replacement labor, downtime); and
  • Quality‑of‑life impacts (pain, suffering, diminished capacity).
Agencies consider these items to quantify the economic harm of crashes. They are neither expenditures nor direct costs paid by any agency. They are economic impact metrics, used to compare alternatives and evaluate safety performance.

More on Rezul News
"Independent analysis has shown that a roundabout-based local road network would reduce dangers, the $334MM project cost, community impact, and construction time," said the No Cloverleaf Coalition, which supports US1 safety upgrades without negative impact to the community. "Under the current plan, every crash at those intersections will be a direct result of PennDOT's failure to prioritize communities as well as US1 motorists."

Contact
Paul Schneider
***@paulschneiderpr.com


Source: No Cloverleaf Coalition

Show All News | Disclaimer | Report Violation

0 Comments

Latest on Rezul News